Systems of Superiority

The Diverging Paths of Harris and Trump

Aug 10, 2024

With the 2024 election looming as a pivotal moment for our nation, we're in uncharted territory. But so is the trajectory of our technology, our ability to annihilate each other with the push of a button, and climate change. Both presidential candidates claim “democracy is at stake,” but the heart of this election comes down to systems of superiority.

It is not just about economic metrics or foreign policy stances; it's about whether we continue to uphold hierarchies that benefit the few or move towards a society that lives up to the principles outlined in our constitution, pledge of allegiance, and songs of freedom.

The Pilgrims' journey from rejecting British superiority to enacting colonial practices highlights the complex dynamics of power and the beliefs operating in our society today. Initially seeking freedom from oppression, they ultimately perpetuated similar systems of dominance through Manifest Destiny, slavery, and other expansionist ideologies. Understanding and critically examining the complexity of this historical narrative is crucial as we strive to realize our aspirations for the future.

There is much to celebrate thanks to progress in the United States, but the dark side is a culture where success is primarily measured by wealth, material possessions, and power. Despite our riches, we're experiencing a collapse of our inner lives, with addiction, depression, and anxiety rampant across all income levels.

Virtually every issue that infuriates me stems from systems of superiority, including restricted abortion access, book banning, underfunded schools, lax gun laws, and the deportation of DACA recipients. The MAGA campaign, driven by our centuries-long insatiable desire for wealth and power, supports these policies by spreading fear and hatred to maintain their perceived superiority. A chilling comment I overheard at a gas station in rural Idaho one day after Trump was shot—“I imagine that Bass Pro Shops are going to have a line out the door today”—highlights the panic that fuels this movement; those benefiting from the current system are clinging on desperately.

Two key factors sustain these systems: internalized privilege and internalized oppression. These psychological mechanisms work in tandem to reinforce social hierarchies and maintain the status quo. Internalized privilege occurs when members of dominant groups unconsciously absorb and accept cultural messages affirming their superiority, leading to a sense of entitlement and justification for one's higher social position. Conversely, internalized oppression affects members of marginalized groups who absorb negative societal messages about their worth and capabilities.

Most people are good, and good people are not consciously oppressive; they have internalized the cultural messages and consider their attitudes towards the other group normal. “It’s just human nature—someone has to be on top,” “She only got the position over me because she is Black,” and “America is not ready to elect a black woman” are prime examples.

Marginalization and oppression stifle our collective imagination, limiting what we believe is possible. Kamala Harris's unexpected popularity stems from a radical shift in this mindset. Her policies aim to dismantle internalized oppression and privilege by promoting equity, justice, and inclusion across the board - from criminal justice reform to environmental justice.

In stark contrast, Trump's policies reinforce existing hierarchies through actions like deporting immigrants, restricting abortion access, removing environmental regulation, and favoring the wealthy with tax cuts. MAGA fan’s support for book banning and school vouchers further entrenches these social divides. While Harris envisions a society where all can thrive, Trump's approach maintains and deepens the systems that hold us back.

I’m not arguing against hierarchy in societies, nor am I arguing for radical socialist policies. I’m just wondering if we can lead the world in rethinking what our hierarchies are based on. Victory for Harris in November is the ultimate metaphor for challenging the myths of superiority based on a scarcity mindset, where resources, opportunities, and power are seen as limited and must be fiercely protected. In contrast, an abundance mindset views resources and opportunities as plentiful and expandable, promoting inclusivity, cooperation, and shared prosperity.

Anyone who says anything is impossible isn't watching the Olympics. The past six weeks have defied all expectations—from the near-miss assassination attempt on Trump to Biden stepping down from the race. This election is not merely about selecting a president; it's about deciding whether our great nation is ready to move forward as a global leader, reject systems of superiority based on a scarcity mindset, and embrace a future where success is measured by compassion, dignity, and the ability to uplift others.

Sources:

The Four I’s of Oppression: The Chinook Fund

Internalized Dominance: New Discourses

PS: Did anyone watch the breaking at the Olympics last night? Can you imagine settling our differences with that kind of dignity?